Investing Reflections On India

Precision Pipes is in the business of manufacturing PVC Profiles and Extrusions for the auto and white goods (refrigerators) industries with autos being the dominant segment (90% of revenues) by far. The company has a prominent customer base including the likes of Maruti, Tata, GM, Toyota etc.  Its white goods customers include the likes of Voltas, Godrej, Videocon etc.  It primarily operates with a cost advantage to global peers and a technological edge to domestic competitors.  It has a technical collaboration with two Japanese companies.  The industry is set to grow at 10%+ over the next decade. The company reported consistent growth in revenues and operating profits over the last five years – reporting over 50cr in operating profits on revenues of over 200cr in the last financial year.  It used no net debt (as at 30 th September, 2011) to finance its operations. It is primarily dependent on PVC prices, which is dependent on crude oil prices a...

HB Estate Developers operates in the real estate industry – constructing hotels, shopping malls and residential properties; and renting commercial space. It is currently involved in hotel construction for Taj Vivanta in Gurgaon.  It also has a 57% interest in a real estate project with Parsvanth Developers costing about 30cr.  The project is currently loss making but is backed by equivalent net assets. Since the company is primarily an investment company, the balance sheet would be more significant to understanding the financial aspects of its operations than the income statement.  The company had over 300cr invested in its main project.  It financed this with 240cr of external debt net of 24cr in cash and liquid assets as at the end of the last financial year. The construction business is subject to the risk of rising material costs (steel, cement etc.).  It is also adversely impacted by crude oil price rises, which impact hotels’ tourism revenue...

Vikram Thermo operates in the pharmaceutical industry and manufactures excipients i.e. inactive drug coating. The company owns the relatively popular ‘DrugCoat’ brand and has a reasonably prominent customer base. The company has reported consistent growth in revenues and profits over the last five years – reporting about 6cr of operating profits on about 30cr of revenues in the last twelve months.  It employed minimal debt in financing its operations. The company did report negative reserves about a decade ago as a result of accumulated losses.  This is largely irrelevant to the business as of today but may be a factor for consideration in case there appear to be indications of aggressive financial policies (e.g. taking on greater debt financing for expansions etc.), which isn’t the case at present. It is exposed to a lot of competition in the generics field (although somewhat mitigated by its brand).  It is also subject to the risk of crude oil price in...

ABC Bearings operates in the automobile industry and manufactures ball and roller bearings. It has a technical collaboration with NSK Japan in manufacturing its products. The company has reported stable revenues and operating profits over the last five years – reporting 42cr of operating profits on revenues of 200cr in the last financial year.  It employed minimal net debt in its operations. The business is subject to intense competition from Chinese/CIS suppliers, who ‘dump’ products in the domestic market below even material cost, as well as the unorganised sector supplying bearings of questionable quality. The business is also exposed to rising steel costs and is generally dependent on the fortunes of the auto and capital goods industry, whose sales largely depend on the interest rate cycle (impacting ease of loan financing for purchases) as well as oil prices (affecting autos). Moreover the company is a net importer and is therefore exposed to a weakening...

Fenoplast is in the business of manufacturing PVC Leather cloth for the automobile industry and PVC Film for the pharmaceutical industry.  It is also attempting to expand its product range to visual packaging (garments, electronic hardware etc.) and the leather footwear segments along with other areas. The company has reported consistent growth in revenues and operating profits over the last five years – reporting almost 15cr in operating profits on revenues of almost 180cr. However, it employed about 50cr in debt financing to generate the above results, which appears uncomfortable and puts the company in a vulnerable position – particularly in the event of a rising interest-rate environment and/or economic slowdown The business is exposed to the risks of rising global petrol prices (raw material) and its fortunes are tied into those of the automobile and pharmaceutical industries – which are, in turn, exposed to the risks of high interest rates, excessive competitio...

Austin Engineering Company (AEC) is in the business of manufacturing bearings for use in various basic industries such as automotive, defense, steel, cement, sugar, paper, agro-machinery etc. AEC has been operating in this industry for the last 30+ years and has an established brand name (‘AECL’) in the domestic bearing market with a wide distribution network and an established customer base. The company has reported reasonably stable operating profits on similarly stable revenues over the last five years barring the last financial year when it reported depressed operating profits of 6cr on revenues of about 80cr.   Previously, it reported average operating profits of about 12cr in the last five years.   It employed minimal net debt (4cr) to generate these results.   Due to the nature of its business, which requires relatively high stocking of inventory, the company has to invest in its working capital that negatively impacts its operating cash flows – but ...

Alphageo is in the business of executing seismic surveys for oil exploration majors such as ONGC, Essar etc. The company has reported reasonably stable revenues and operating profits over the last five years except for a dip in profitability in the last financial year as well as last quarter.   It operated average operating profits of about 30cr in the last five years on revenues of about 75cr.   It employed no net debt as at 31 st March, 2011. The business is subject to risks of international competition from reputed players, crude oil price drops, technological obsolescence, manpower retention, government policies on oil exploration, highly lumpy revenues including periods of significant revenue and earnings downturns in lean times, cost underestimation on long-term projects, legal risks of non-compliance with laws and regulations, etc.

Prima Plastics is in the business of manufacturing Moulded Furniture and Aluminium Composite Panels.   It supplies usually to retail outlets.   It also owns a profitable joint venture in Cameroon. The company has reported reasonably consistent growth in revenues and operating profits over the last five years.   It reported almost 6cr in operating profits on revenues of almost 60cr in the last financial year while employing modest net debt of about 3cr. The business is exposed to high risk of poor performance in recessionary conditions.   It is also exposed to crude oil and aluminium price spikes, polypropylene (plastic) supplies - mainly dependent on Middle East capacity, heavy competition incl from China, price competition in low-value products, foreign exchange risks on imports as well as exports, etc. Management initiated dividends in FY’10 and continued it in FY’11.   Its continuance would appear to depend on the impact of business risks menti...

Vinati Organics is in the business of supplying chemicals – specifically it supplies IBB (intermediate) for manufacturing Ibuprofen and ATBS (monomers) used in oil-field recovery, water treatment, acrylics manufacturing etc. The company holds leading competitive positions in its industries – it’s the largest supplier of IBB in the world and second largest supplier of ATBS in the world. The company has reported consistent growth in revenues and operating profits over the last five years – reporting 64cr in operating profits on revenues of over 315cr in the last financial year while operating with modest net debt of about 75cr. The business is exposed to the risks of economic downturns, crude oil price declines, weakening of US$ and lack of skilled labour.

Enkei Castalloy is in the business of supplying aluminium castings to the auto industry and also to the agriculture, locomotive and other capital equipment industries. The company has reported reasonably stable operating profits on somewhat stable revenues on a standalone basis – reporting 37cr of operating profits on 257cr of revenues in the last financial year and about 40cr and 350cr respectively on a consolidated basis.   It may be relevant note, however, that net profits (standalone) have been somewhat erratic presumably due to unsound financial policies on borrowing in the past.   It currently operates with a somewhat reasonable net debt load of 74cr (consolidated) as at 31 st March, 2011. The business requires heavy investments in working capital hitting operating cash flow generation.   It is subject to the risks of aluminium price spikes, crude oil price rises and road development progress (affecting autos), heavy competition from Chinese manufacturer...

Indian Acrylics is in the business of supplying acrylic fibre. The company has reported somewhat erratic profits on reasonably stable revenues including losses in 2009.   It reported about 56cr of operating profits on revenues of about 410 crores in the last financial year and operated with moderate net debt of about 80cr. The company was forced to restructure its external loans as a result of heavy losses during the recession implying a lack of strength during hard times.   It is a cyclical business exposed to risks of foreign dumping, Acrylonitrite (raw material) price spikes – which is dependent on crude oil prices, technological obsolescence of existing machinery etc.   Management have also diverted its attention to non-core ventures such as power generation, carbon credits etc. – in which it doesn’t appear to have demonstrable business experience.   Their lack of stewardship towards minority shareholders is confirmed with the lack of dividends in ...

Tokyo Plast is in the business of manufacturing thermoware products used to maintain temperature such as insulated ice boxes, water bottles, food carriers etc. The company has reported reasonable growth in revenues and operating profits over the last five years – reporting about 7cr in operating profits on revenues of about 50cr in the last financial year.  It operated with a modest net debt position of about 13cr. The business is subject to crude oil price spikes impacting its raw material costs.  It is also exposed to Chinese competition in this product category and adverse movements in foreign exchange with a large proportion of exports constituting its total sales.

Ecoplast is in the business of manufacturing and supplying co-extruded packaging film, which is apparently a higher value-added packaging film. The company has reported growth in revenues and profits over the last five years.   It reported operating profits of about 6.6cr on revenues of 66cr in the last financial year.   It operated with a modest net debt of about 8cr. The business is exposed to rises in its raw material prices (poly-ethylene – petroleum based).   It is also subject to risks of increased competition as a result of low barriers to entry in this industry and adverse foreign exchange movements on purchase since it imports a large proportion of its raw materials.

Puneet Resins is in the business of manufacturing and trading rubber products for supply to the non-tyre segment of rubber users. The sales mix of trading revenues to manufacturing revenues varies widely from year to year depending on demand conditions. The company has reported consistent growth in revenues and profits over the last five years.   It reported operating profits of 7cr on revenues of about 50cr in the last financial year.   It operated with no net debt. The business is subject to price spikes of its raw materials (PVC, Synthetic Rubber etc.).   It is exposed to further weakening in its negotiating power with suppliers as a result of increasing importance of competing (petroleum-based) user industries.   It also has apparently little pricing power with its end customers.

APM Industries is in the business of producing spun yarn fibre – it is primarily an exporter of man-made spun yarn fibre. The company hasn’t shown spectacular growth in revenues over the last five years but has reasonable operating profitability given the industry it operates in.  It reported 30cr in operating profits on 240cr of revenues in the last financial year.  It operated with a reasonably high debt load of 60cr, which would sensitise its net profitability in the event of high interest rates (as we have now) and during industry/economic downturns. It is exposed to the persistent cyclicality in the textile industry marked by consistent oversupply.  Moreover, it is operating in a highly capital intensive industry and heavily subject to government regulations on imports/exports/duties/taxes etc.  It is also exposed to crude oil price spikes (impacting synthetic rubber used in man-made fibre), adverse foreign exchange movements (export-driven revenues), and a s...

Asahi Songwon is in the business of manufacturing phthalocyanine pigments for the chemical industry. It supplies to leading chemical companies such as BASF, Clariant etc. The company has reported growth in revenues and profits over the last five years – reporting about 30cr in operating profits on 185cr of revenues in the last financial year.  It operated with a modest leverage of 45cr (as at 31 st March, 2011). The business, however, generates weak cash flows due to high working capital requirements. The business is exposed to the risk of crude oil price spikes since it constitutes a major raw material cost.  Moreover, it is dependent on a few key customers and any loss of customers would seem to have a devastating impact on its earning power.  It is also exposed to adverse foreign exchange movements since over 90% of revenues is comprised of exports.  Furthermore, being a small player in the chemical industry exposes it to global competition in the same produ...

IG Petrochemicals is in the business of manufacturing Phthalic Anhydride – used as a petrochemical in manufacturing paints. It supplies the product to leading paint companies including the likes of Nerolac. The company hasn’t really grown its revenues and profits over the last four years – reporting about 45cr of operating profits on 630cr of revenues in the last financial year.  It operated with modest net debt of about 45cr (as at 30 th September, 2010). The business is subject to several risks including crude oil price rises, adverse foreign exchange movements on raw material supplies, import competition via lax government regulation, cyclicality – business fluctuates with the construction cycle etc.  Moreover, there were plant fires in the recent past calling into question the safety regulations in place at the plant. Management haven’t declared a dividend in the last three years, which is inexplicable since it doesn’t appear to be deploying funds for profitable grow...